Credit, Getty Images

Just hours after beginning the large-scale invasion of Ukraine, on February 24, 2022, the President of Russia, Vladimir Putin, gathered the country's richest men in the immense Yekaterininsky Hall, in the Kremlin, seat of the Russian government.

More than 36 businesspeople were sitting close to each other, along one of the walls, wearing protective masks because of the Covid-19 pandemic. A Russian newspaper reporter described them as "pale and looking as if they had not slept."

Upon entering, Putin sat on the other side of the room, keeping a wide distance from the businesspeople. As usual, he was not wearing a mask.

In his usual indirect speech, Putin said he expected their support for the war.

"I would ask you to understand what is happening," Putin said, "and work together with the government to find ways to support production, the economy and jobs."

In the video of the meeting released by the Kremlin, none of the invited billionaires said a word.

End of content

This silence has become a characteristic of Russia's super-rich. Over the decades with Putin in power, they have learned that publicly criticizing him can be costly.

In 2003, oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky, then Russia's richest man and financier of several opposition groups, accused Putin of allowing widespread corruption in the country.

End of Most read

Khodorkovsky spent the next ten years in prison, convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement, in an episode that served as a warning to other potential critics of the Russian president. He denies committing these crimes.

Credit, ALEXEY NIKOLSKY/SPUTNIK/AFP via Getty Images

And even though some of these super-rich people are against war, they tend to keep their opinions to themselves.

But despite the silence, there are signs of change: some members of the once-powerful Russian business elite seem to be beginning to imagine what the country would be like after Putin. They wonder whether, when the president leaves power or dies, Russia could return to the way it was in the 1990s, when oligarchs enjoyed the privileges of power, or whether a healthier political environment could emerge.

Journalist Arkady Ostrovsky, an expert on Russian politics for the British magazine The Economist, who recently spent hours interviewing one of Russia's richest men, says he notices a "historic political shift" in the way the super-rich see the country's future.

Dissatisfied tycoons

Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service

Download here

End of app promotion

The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 gave rise to a new political force in Russia: businessmen who took advantage of the end of communism to accumulate extraordinary fortunes and then began trying to influence politicians for their own benefit. They became known as "oligarchs", in reference to the term oligarchy, of Greek origin, which means "rule by the few". At that time, money was synonymous with power.

It was during this period, known as the "turbulent 1990s", that the so-called "new Russians" emerged. Large state-owned companies were put up for sale, and men with the right connections became millionaires, even billionaires, practically overnight. Corruption was widespread, cronyism was widespread, and contract killings were frequent.

But shortly after being elected president for the first time in 2000, Putin brought the oligarchs under his control. He had no interest in sharing power with anyone. The president was able to confront the billionaires because the Russian economy was recovering and the central government was gaining strength.

Credit, NurPhoto/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Bill Browder, an investor who was once the largest foreign investor in Russia and was banned from entering the country in 2005 after campaigning against corruption, claims that the super-rich Russians were intimidated and submissive to Putin. This happened, for example, at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, in the years before the war, when they were still welcome at the event.

"I remember seeing the oligarchs walking around like they owned the place, extremely arrogant and confident. But when Putin showed up, it was amazing to see how these men who were supposed to be super-powered alpha macho men turned into completely submissive, almost desperate children," Browder told the BBC.

Since the start of the war in 2022, Russia has kept the country's richest businessmen under control with a relentless policy of rewards and punishments (a kind of bite and blow). Critics of the war had their assets confiscated, while government allies benefited from lucrative contracts related to the conflict. Today, Russia has more billionaires than ever: there are 155, according to Forbes magazine. Their combined fortune reached a record of almost US$700 billion (about R$4 trillion).

But even among the tycoons who remained loyal to Putin and were rewarded, all that money appears not to be enough to guarantee satisfaction. Some are increasingly restless.

Autocracy, oligarchy or democracy?

The billions that Russian tycoons have accumulated no longer have the same weight as before. In Russia, money no longer buys them much political influence.

“They have no tricks up their sleeves and no negotiating power,” says Dmitry Nekrasov, a former Kremlin adviser, ex-opposition politician and exiled analyst. "They are rich because they have some connection with Putin, not the other way around."

Outside Russia, tycoons also face isolation caused by sanctions imposed by the West following the large-scale invasion of Ukraine.

"They are treated like low-level criminals. They can't travel on their private jets. Their yachts can't dock in the best ports in Europe. It must be a terrible and humiliating situation for them," says Browder, an outspoken critic of Putin.

Therefore, some of these businesspeople began to discreetly think about what will happen when Putin leaves power. This is what well-informed analysts, who closely follow the universe of these tycoons, tell me.

There are no signs that the president is about to leave office, nor any reason to believe that he is having health problems. But Putin, who turned 74 last month, has been in power for a quarter of a century. In Moscow, everyone knows that one day he will leave the Kremlin.

Asked by the Reuters agency last year whether he intended to remain in office until 2036, when the term stipulated by the Constitution ends, Putin replied: "Only God knows if we will have enough health."

Credit, CARL DE SOUZA/AFP via Getty Images

If Putin were to resign or die in office, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin would assume power. But Mishustin did not demonstrate presidential ambitions, which was probably one of the main reasons for his appointment. This would create a kind of power vacuum.

In this scenario, experts on Russia-related issues with whom I spoke point out some possibilities.

Some in the West, and certainly in Russia as well, hope that democracy can thrive in the country after Putin's departure, with a government run by the people rather than a new group of oligarchs or a single authoritarian leader. But, according to analysts, this seems to be the least likely scenario. Important democratic institutions were weakened or destroyed during Putin's rule.

“Russia is so used to violence that it has lost the habit of following traditional democratic procedures,” says Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian journalist and analyst.

Another possibility is the continuation of authoritarianism. A new leader could replace Putin and maintain his policy of repression.

But Prokopenko believes this would not result in another dictatorship led by a strong leader, at least not immediately. According to the journalist, this type of regime takes time to consolidate. Initially, Putin's successor would have less power and fewer resources than him.

There is also a third possibility: the tycoons regain their power and Russia returns to a system similar to the oligarchy of the 1990s. Nekrasov, a former Kremlin advisor and former opposition politician who now lives in exile, says that, in this scenario, the country would be governed by a small group of powerful elite clans, allied with business interests.

This last option, of course, is the favorite of many tycoons. "They would like to go back to the time when they were listened to, when their assets were not confiscated and when they knew the rules of the game," says journalist Prokopenko, who spent a lot of time talking to Russia's richest businessmen.

Although the power of these tycoons has been greatly reduced since the 1990s, it is still worth paying attention to what they say. Given their immense fortunes, it seems likely that, sooner or later, they will try to regain their political influence.

Some are already "trying to get close to the right people in the security services or among ministers," says Nekrasov, the exiled politician. But, according to him, any initiative beyond that would be “too dangerous”.

Credit, Vladimir Smirnov SPUTNIK/KREMLIN POOL/EPA/Shutterstock

According to Nekrasov, the behavior of tycoons in the coming years will depend, in part, on their financial situation. Those who have a lot of money available will have more confidence to "enter the political game" and compete for positions of power, preparing for a Russia without Putin. Those who depend on public contracts or the government's good will will be afraid to act, due to the risk of losing everything, he says.

Prokopenko says there has already been a change in the way businesspeople refer to Putin. Before, they called him "Nachalnik" ("boss", in free translation), "Perviy" ("first") or simply by the initials "VV", nicknames that showed a certain respect. Now they call him "Ded", which Prokopenko describes as "a hint of contempt". The term can be translated as "old man" or "grandpa", a much less respectful way of referring to the president.

Some wealthy Russians want "politics to become part of people's lives again", says the journalist, with less repression, more freedom of expression and healthier competition between parties and politicians.

But, according to Prokopenko, the climate of repression in Russia means that, for now, these businesspeople are too afraid to try to promote change. Prokopenko interviewed a tycoon who spent the entire conversation sitting on his cell phone, believing that this would make possible digital espionage by the secret police difficult.

"I thought it was a typically Stalinist fear. Completely irrational," he says.

A surprising interview

An important clue about what Russian tycoons expect from a future without Putin came from Andrey Melnichenko, known as the world's fertilizer king and currently Russia's eighth richest man.

Earlier this year, he raised eyebrows by giving an interview to the British magazine The Economist, something rare among wealthy businessmen in Russia, especially when it comes to a publication from a country considered hostile by the Kremlin. The newspaper also published an opinion article written by him.

In some excerpts of the interview, Melnichenko repeated the Kremlin's arguments. He stated that Ukraine is the scene of a confrontation between Russia and the West and that, in his opinion, Western countries have ignored Russian security concerns and threaten the country's sovereignty.

But the interview got more interesting from there. Melnichenko did not defend Putin's departure from power, but he made an important reservation: he argued in favor of a change that would end the concentration of power in the hands of a single person in Russia. He also stated that the country needs to expand its relations with the rest of the world.

Prokopenko believes the tycoon tried to stimulate a public debate. According to her, it was a "call for rich people like him to start speaking out."

The journalist who interviewed him, Arkady Ostrovsky, told the BBC that the two had "intense and heated discussions" in "hotels and cafes, drinking coffee, lots of coffee, and sometimes smoking."

According to Ostrovsky, the businessman seemed to "really reflect" on his answers, instead of resorting to the calculated speech typical of politicians.

Nothing is simple in Russia, and most of those who follow the Russian situation believe that the interview likely took place with some kind of authorization from the Kremlin, explicit or tacit. It is not known why authorities would have agreed to such an unusual request for changes. One possibility is that they wanted to demonstrate that there still exists some degree of political pluralism in the country.

No other tycoon spoke out in support of Melnichenko. Still, Ostrovsky believes that the businessman was not only speaking for himself, but also on behalf of other members of the Russian business elite.

Credit, Andrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Some of them hope that, after Putin's departure, Russia will transform into an "oligarchic republic", as journalist Ostrovsky defines it, similar to what existed in the 1990s, when the business elite exercised great influence over power.

Based on his years of reporting on Russia, Ostrovsky asserts that many of the country's super-rich today have a "sense of being in a dead end, to which this war has led Russia... [an] absence of future."

But although the tycoons are thinking about the future, it seems unlikely that they will take any initiative anytime soon.

Browder, a critic of Putin, states that, despite the dissatisfaction of many of them, it is unlikely that businesspeople would conspire against the president while he is alive. "They know that if they do anything to challenge Putin, he will kill them. And Putin is a very paranoid guy."

American investor Mike Calvey, once a leading investor in Russia, agrees. "What can they do other than end up straight in prison and lose their assets? It's easy for people in London to say, 'Why don't you all get together, stand up to the government and go straight to prison?' Because that's exactly what would happen."

Russia's richest men were once able to influence decisions at the highest levels of power. When Putin leaves the government, there is no doubt that they will try to regain the influence they had in the past.

The question is: will the members of the current regime who remain in power allow this?

Discover more

Watch

End of Watch

Top news

How Russia's super-rich already imagine a future without Putin

COP31 ends without agreement after impasse over fossil fuels

'I was coerced into having a child': how a billionaire tricked successful DJ Liv Nervo into getting pregnant

read more

Most clicked