The most emblematic area of ​​Donald Trump's second government, immigration management, has generated the first change in his cabinet. Kristi Noem, who attracted the president for her energy and toughness of character, was removed after a series of catastrophic hearings before the Senate and House Judiciary Committees, in which she claimed that Trump had approved her controversial advertising campaign, only to be denied shortly after by the president.

First modification: 03/06/2026 - 02:01

Kristi Noem has been one of the highest-profile officials in Donald Trump's second administration. But the head of the Secretary of Homeland Security (DHS) had been pilloried after the violent immigration raids in Minnesota.

Finally, the woman who came to show herself riding in front of the sculpted heads of the founding fathers on Mount Rushmore, as a guarantor of internal security, was removed after two months of bipartisan pressure.

To display this content from X (Twitter), you must allow audience measurement and advertising cookies.

Noem was reassigned to a future position as special envoy for the Shield of the Americas, the summit with right-wing Latin American leaders with whom Trump plans to outline his hemispheric surveillance strategies, but the new functions do not erase the perception that she is leaving through the back door.

Questions about its handling of the immigration issue keep the DHS budget frozen, on which the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Service (ICE) and the Border Patrol (CBP), but also the Coast Guard and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), among other entities in the security area, depend.

To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.

It is a new government shutdown, although in this case partial, in which both Democratic and Republican legislators agree, demanding explanations and a new framework for action by federal agents in handling the immigration issue, after two American citizens were shot dead in the Minnesota raids.

Two devastating hearings before the Judiciary Committees of both the Senate and the House of Representatives ended up putting an end to Noem's management, and opening the door to Oklahoma Senator Markwayne Mullin, President Trump's new nominee, who must be endorsed by Congress.

But the departure occurs not because of what legislators questioned most vigorously, the excesses of ICE and CBP, but because of its hesitant stance when confronted with evidence of irregularities in the granting of advertising contracts.

This is the review of the controversies that Kristi Noem generated in 14 months at the head of the DHS:

A high-profile campaign with little transparency

Much of the questioning from the House Judiciary Committee focused on the process of hiring companies for a $220 million advertising campaign aimed at promoting the immigration agenda, with Noem as the visible head of the efforts.

But the woman who earned Trump's respect for an anecdote in her autobiography in which she recounted how she shot and killed her own dog, fed up with his undocile temperament and poor performance on hunting expeditions, collapsed when she began to be pressured about granting those contracts.

"It's fraud and, ultimately, I think there's going to be accountability," said Rep. Joe Neguse, D-Colorado, when he detailed during the hearing how DHS offered the campaign to just four companies, instead of opening a competitive bid, citing the urgency of fighting illegal immigration.

Noem defended herself by saying that there was “a competitive process” and that “everything was done correctly, everything legally,” but the AP agency and the investigative journalism portal ProPublica had revealed that among those hired were two companies linked to relevant figures within the Republican Party.

One of them, Safe America Media, was incorporated in Delaware a week before the award of a $143 million contract, according to federal records.

One subcontractor for Safe America Media was Strategy Group, a company run by former DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin's husband, Ben Yoho, although he has maintained that he only received $226,000 for his services.

"So your former deputy secretary and her husband are the ones who got the Safe America subcontract. That's what the records show, is there any discrepancy about that?" asked Vermont Democratic Senator Peter Welch, to which Noem responded "no, there are no discrepancies."

Louisiana Republican John Kennedy pressed her further, asking if "the president approved in advance for me to spend $220 million on television ads across the country in which you are prominently featured."

"Yes, sir. We went through the legal procedures, we did it correctly," Noel responded, but Trump denied her two days later, stating that "I never knew anything about it," in a telephone interview with the Reuters agency.

It was the last reference to Noem by Trump before the impeachment, which he announced in Truth Social, noting that the outgoing Secretary of Security “has served us well and has had numerous spectacular results (especially on the border!).”

To display this Truth Social content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

The tough hand against migration

Kristi Noem led several of Trump's most contested immigration policies, from sending more than 200 men to the CECOT mega-prison in El Salvador (some of whom are now suing the administration) to violent raids in Los Angeles, Chicago, Charlotte, Minnesota, and New Orleans.

After months of vindicating the excesses of ICE and CBP, in which DHS published degrading videos about immigrants whom it called “the worst of the worst,” Noem did not change her position during the questions in Congress.

He maintained his claims that Renee Good and Alex Pretti, murdered in Minnesota by ICE and CBP officers (respectively), were “domestic terrorists,” as was Marimar Martínez, another American citizen who was shot during Operation Midway Blitz in Chicago, who survived and was present at the arrest.

"I was getting reports from the ground, from officers on the scene," Noem said when Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin urged her to recant. "I make every effort to provide factual information."

Noem was the visible face of the deportation to CECOT, where she traveled to record a video in front of a group of imprisoned men.

He appeared in official messages in camouflage clothing, wielding machine guns, wearing bulletproof vests or validating snipers stationed on rooftops to confront unarmed protesters in Chicago.

She ended the Temporary Protected Status (TPS) of Venezuelans and Haitians, among other nationalities, giving rise to several judicial processes that have managed to stop some of her decisions, and it was she who recommended to Trump the travel ban and visa restrictions that affect a total of 99 countries.

She was also the main defender of the masked ICE officers, who resort to racial profiling to define objectives, keep children imprisoned in detention centers and have confronted migrants and citizens who protest their actions alike.

It was she who elevated the controversial CBP commander Gregory Bovino, relegated to minor duties after the chaos in Minnesota, and she was also the one who was displaced from immigration management in that state, which ended up being entrusted to the so-called 'border czar' Tom Homan.

In the end, Trump has paid, losing approval in the only aspect that still had a positive rating in the polls, the immigration issue.

A Reuters/Ipsos poll conducted in February revealed that, although Americans continue to support the deportation of undocumented immigrants, 60% consider that enforcement agents of the immigration agenda have gone too far.

"We're starting to make the American people think that deporting people is wrong. It's just the opposite. The way you're deporting them is wrong," Sen. Thom Tillis, R-North Carolina, told Noem during the March 3 hearing.

With AP, Reuters and local media

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.