Just hours after threatening Iran with total destruction, the US president announced a two-week ceasefire on Tuesday night, April 7. A lightning turn that illustrates, according to analysts, a strategy that combines extreme intimidation, contradictions and Trump's attempt to regain control of the speech. "It has damaged his credibility. The danger is that no one will take him seriously anymore."

First modification: 04/09/2026 - 04:07

Threaten to “eradicate a civilization” and then negotiate. On Tuesday morning, April 7, the US president issued an ultimatum to the Iranian leadership: reopen the Strait of Hormuz before nightfall; Otherwise, “an entire civilization would die that night, never to appear again,” he stated on his Truth Social platform. He added: “I don't want that to happen, but it probably will.” An unusual threat of violence, unparalleled in the contemporary rhetoric of an American president.

To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.

Less than ten hours later, close to the deadline, events took a turn: Trump announced that he had accepted a two-week ceasefire with Tehran, which was immediately presented as a “total and complete victory” for Washington, although violations of the truce and errors of interpretation have already been pointed out.

“It is the sign of a cornered man.”

For many observers, this verbal escalation marks a new threshold. “It is the sign of a cornered man,” analyzes Steven Ekovich, professor emeritus at the American University of Paris. "He is between a rock and a hard place, with no way out. His words reflect deep frustration. The Iranians could see in it a weakness rather than a show of strength," he added.

“Intimidate the opponent”

This strategy, however, is part of a certain continuity. Donald Trump has turned his “unfiltered” personality into a political tool. Already in 2017, during his first term, he promised “fire and fury” to North Korea, brandishing the nuclear threat, before entering into unprecedented talks with Kim Jong-un.

For Jérôme Viala-Gaudefroy, senior professor at Sciences-Po Saint-Germain-en-Laye and specialist in the United States, this position responds to a well-identified logic: "Donald Trump sets the bar very high because he believes it is the solution to scare the adversary. He believes that this extreme pressure will force the adversary to negotiate and give him an advantage. However, he is in a position of weakness vis-à-vis Iran."

Because, deep down, the end of the war in the Middle East still seems far away. A ten-point proposal transmitted by Tehran will be discussed in the negotiations that will begin on Friday in Pakistan, according to the official Iranian press. A list published by the Islamic Republic mentions “maintaining Iranian control over the Strait of Hormuz, accepting enrichment, lifting all primary and secondary sanctions,” as well as withdrawing US forces from the Middle East. Conditions difficult to reconcile with the objectives declared by Washington.

“Despite his violent statements, Trump actually achieves nothing and finds himself trapped in a situation that he himself caused,” says Jérôme Viala-Gaudefroy. "It is a Trump-style exit, a rhetorical exit. He constructs a narrative in which he appears as the winner, transforming reality by stating that the Iranians are forced to negotiate, when in reality, if they accept the ten points of the peace plan, the situation could be worse than before the war," he says.

For his part, a senior White House official assured that the plan publicly released by Iran was not the document that served as the basis for negotiations with the United States.

Read alsoMiddle East, on hold: 40 days of conflict leave death, destruction and lasting damage

Beyond words, his statements also raise questions of International Law. When he threatens to destroy Iran's power grid and return the country's 90 million inhabitants “to the Stone Age,” Donald Trump does not rule out acts considered war crimes.

Democratic Representative Jason Crow recalled on CNN that the military has an obligation to refuse to carry out illegal orders: “If you are asked to attack civilians, if you are asked to kill women and children, if you are asked to kill non-combatants, if you are asked to bomb a school, if you are asked to bomb a civilian power plant, that would be a war crime.”

The same goes for threats of total annihilation of Iran, which have fueled speculation about possible use of nuclear weapons.

Speaking to Reuters, Brian Finucane, a former State Department legal adviser who now works for the International Crisis Group, believes that these statements “could be interpreted as a threat to commit genocide” in light of US and international law.

The confusion is even greater because the American president's messages contradict each other. Two days before his ultimatum expired, he posted in Truth Social: “Open up fucking Detroit, you fucking crazy people, or you'll live in hell—YOU WILL SEE!” And he added: “Glory to Allah.” On Tuesday, in the message in which he threatened to annihilate Iran, he also mentioned the possibility of a diplomatic compromise, concluding with: “May God bless the great people of Iran.”

Keep “the whole world in suspense”

In any case, the sequence illustrates an already well-established pattern: bringing the threat to its peak and then adjusting the posture to the risks of escalation. A dynamic that is also part of a tense internal political context, marked by public opinion more resistant to war and by growing economic concerns, as the midterm elections approach.

For Steven Ekovich, the logic also lies elsewhere: "Donald Trump's strategy is to be the center of world attention. He kept the entire world in suspense for a few hours after his threat on Tuesday. But he has also damaged his credibility. The danger is that no one will take him seriously anymore."

In the United States, the reactions are intense. Trump's opponents question his mental health and interpret his latest statements as evidence that he is sinking into dementia. “The president's mental faculties are collapsing,” denounced progressive representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. “The time has come to say no” to the president, launched the influential far-right commentator Tucker Carlson, addressing senior officials in the White House and the Army.

Read also "They were tested and they failed": Trump's attack before his meeting with the head of NATO

Many Democrats and some opposition Republicans have even advocated resorting to the 25th Amendment. This allows, through a binding procedure, to forcibly remove a president who is considered incapable of carrying out his duties.

For their part, Massachusetts Senator Ed Markey and Seth Moulton, representative of the same state in the House of Representatives, have called for an impeachment process to be initiated against the American president.

“Trump cannot simply threaten to commit war crimes with complete impunity,” summarized Ed Markey.

“Trump cannot simply threaten to commit war crimes with complete impunity,” summarized Ed Markey. During his first term, Trump has already survived two procedures, in both cases thanks to a negative vote from the Senate, in February 2020 and then in February 2021.

This article is adapted from its French version

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.