Soissons (France) (AFP) – Four years of suspended prison time were requested Thursday against Christophe Ellul, tried for the death of his partner Elisa Pilarski, killed in 2019 by bites attributed to her pitbull Curtis, whose prosecutor requested euthanasia.

Published on: 03/05/2026 - 12:43 Modified on: 03/05/2026 - 17:11

Christophe Ellul, 51, is on trial in Soissons (Aisne) for the involuntary homicide of Elisa Pilarski, 29 years old and six months pregnant, whose corpse he discovered on November 16, 2019 covered in dog bites in a forest in the region.

The young woman was walking one of Mr. Ellul's dogs, Curtis, to whom the investigation attributed the bites. Now eight years old, the animal has been living in a kennel since the tragedy.

The investigation established that it was an American Pitbull Terrier illegally imported into France, because it had not been declared to the authorities.

The prosecutor, however, is "not certain" that its possession is prohibited in France, the legislation being vague concerning this type of dog.

Mr. Ellul is notably accused of “biting” training, banned in France.

“I don’t think you were aware of mistreating these dogs” and training them in a dangerous manner, added the prosecutor, Laureydane Ortuno.

The prosecutor therefore asked to rule out the aggravating circumstances and to "take into account the age of the facts", the absence of a criminal record for Christophe Ellul, the fact that he was "socially integrated" and that he was "hugely affected" by the death of Elisa Pilarski.

She therefore did not ask for a prison sentence, although he faces five years in prison in the absence of aggravating circumstances and ten if at least two are retained.

By adopting Curtis and then training him in practices that could amount to "biting", "you imported a weapon and you chambered it", underlined the prosecutor during her closing arguments.

“Terribly locked”

"Mr. Ellul, you asked for proof of Curtis' involvement (...) I don't know, sir, if we managed to bring you this evidence, I don't know where you are. (...) I have the impression that you are terribly closed off, I don't know if it's denial, a lie", she continued.

After several years of rejecting the involvement of his dog, which would have made him responsible for the tragedy, Mr. Ellul ended up recognizing on Wednesday that he had "proof" that his dog was "guilty".

“The measurements (of the bites, editor’s note) apparently speak for themselves. Today, yes, I accept it and I believe it,” he declared at the hearing.

An expert examination determined that the exploitable bite marks matched Curtis' physical characteristics.

But Thursday morning, the 50-year-old refused to repeat his remarks, saying he had "not made a confession. I told Madam President, from the start, what I wanted, that's all."

A formula that maintains ambiguity. On Tuesday, Christophe Ellul assured: “If Curtis is guilty, prick him or I will do it, but put the evidence on the table.”

“It’s Curtis.”

Throughout the trial, Christophe Ellul assured that the dog, which he had adopted at the age of three months and which was two years old at the time of the tragedy, had "never" been aggressive in the past.

“It is entirely possible that your dog, the first time it bit, was to kill Elisa,” the prosecutor replied during the requisitions.

Mr. Ellul had, from the beginning, defended the thesis of a possible involvement of a pack of dogs hunting in the area, although various analyzes during the investigation, in particular DNA, directed the bundle of clues towards Curtis alone.

These convolutions exasperated the lawyer of a national hunting association, Guillaume Demarcq, who called on him, in the name of his love for Elisa, to "tell the truth" and "think" of the victim's family, whose mother and uncle are present in court.

“The small percentage of doubt that I still had in the back of my head, I no longer have it,” said Elisa Pilarski’s mother, Nathalie Labastarde. “Everything leads us to believe that it was Curtis who attacked Elisa.”

She estimated that the final phone call made by her daughter to Christophe Ellul at 1:19 p.m. on the day of the tragedy, a few minutes before her death, was perhaps a sign that Curtis was attacking her and that she hoped to calm him down by making him hear his master's voice.

© 2026 AFP

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.