The petition against MP Caroline Yadan's bill exceeded 500,000 signatures on Tuesday, paving the way for a debate on the text in Parliament. The proposed law aims to fight against “renewed forms” of anti-Semitism but is accused of “confusing” it with criticism of Israel.
Published on: 04/08/2026 - 11:02
MP Caroline Yadan's bill against "renewed forms" of anti-Semitism will be the subject of a debate in Parliament. The petition against this text, accused of making a "conflation" with criticism of Israel, exceeded 500,000 signatures on Tuesday April 8, the threshold required for it to be examined during a debate without a vote in the hemicycle.
After the one against the controversial Duplomb law last summer, this is the second petition launched on the National Assembly website to reach the half-million signature mark.
Also read: Why is the proposed law against “renewed forms of anti-Semitism” controversial?
The text asks deputies to oppose the adoption of this bill which broadens the offense of advocating terrorism and creates an offense of calling for the destruction of a State – bill which will be examined in the Assembly chamber on April 16 and 17.
"We may fear" that this text will lead to "forcing judges to make this amalgamation between anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism in order to silence any criticism against Israel", we read in the petition, filed on February 18 by a 26-year-old job seeker.
When questioned, Caroline Yadan believes that "the petition concerns a communication based on factual untruths", indicating that the text resulting from the commission is not the one submitted at the end of 2024 but takes into account the recommendations issued by the Council of State, which she herself referred to. To AFP, she affirmed that “her determination is intact”.
A text which “misses its target”, according to the PS
The mobilization seems to weigh on the balance of political power.
“The socialist group will vote against the PPL (proposed law) Yadan,” wrote Tuesday morning on X the first secretary of the Socialist Party, Olivier Faure. “Decision taken this morning almost unanimously.”
The socialists are worried about the "legal vagueness" around the text, which "misses its target" and establishes an "essentialization between the Jews of France and the State of Israel", one of the group's spokespersons, Romain Eskenazi, detailed to AFP.
“In a real democracy, the text should simply be removed from the agenda,” noting the success of the petition, declared La France insoumise MP Gabrielle Cathala at a press conference.
The MoDem group, support of the government, also expressed its reservations, pleading for its at least temporary withdrawal from the agenda. "The geopolitical situation is not calm. However, on this type of text, we need appeasement and (...) to be able to take a little step back, so we are very reserved", declared the group's spokesperson, Perrine Goulet, at a press conference, proposing a "temporary withdrawal".
In the history of the Fifth Republic, only one petition was the subject of debate in February. This targeted the controversial Duplomb law on agriculture, an article of which on pesticides had been censored by the Constitutional Council.
With AFP
Keywords associated with the article
The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.




