The ceasefire announced after six weeks of the United States and Israel's war against Iran is going through its first days with signs of fragility. Israeli bombings in Lebanon, the militarization of the Strait of Hormuz and deep disagreements over the Iranian nuclear program configure a scenario in which, for now, the truce seems more like a precarious parenthesis than a consolidated agreement. Below are the key issues that could collapse the provisional pact and negotiations for a long-term cessation of hostilities.

First modification: 04/09/2026 - 18:44 Last modification: 04/10/2026 - 17:41

The ceasefire between the United States, Israel and Iran enters a risk zone due to military, energy and nuclear disputes.

Added to this are ambiguities in the pact itself and internal political pressures that make progress towards substantive negotiations difficult.

The start of talks between the parties is scheduled for this weekend, as announced by Pakistan, the main mediator of the agreement. And the Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, also gave the green light this Thursday for the start of direct negotiations with Lebanon. But the multiple sources of tension mean that the ceasefire hangs by a thread.

Lebanon under Israeli fire, the biggest immediate challenge to the truce

Despite Netanyahu's recent announcement, the main factor of instability is in Lebanon. Israel launched the most intense attacks against Beirut and the south of the country since the start of the current escalation, on Wednesday, April 8, precisely on the first day of the truce with Iran. Their actions left more than 200 dead and more than a thousand injured on that day alone, indicated the Lebanese Ministry of Health. The magnitude of the bombings, which included densely populated areas and caused scenes of devastation, has called into question the viability of the ceasefire just hours after it was announced.

The dispute revolves around whether or not the agreement included the front between Israel and Hezbollah. Israel and the United States maintain that Lebanon was left out of the truce, while Iran, Pakistan - which acted as a mediator - and several European countries affirm that the ceasefire should cover the entire region.

This divergence is not minor. For Tehran, the attacks against Hezbollah – one of its main regional allies – constitute a direct violation of the agreement. In the early hours of this April 9, the president of the Iranian Parliament, Mohammad Bagher Qalibaf, warned that the continuation of the bombings would have "strong responses", while the Israeli Government reiterated that it would continue to attack with "strength, precision and determination."

The Soufan Center, a New York-based think tank, warned that even if Lebanon were not formally included, the magnitude of the Israeli attacks could be interpreted as an escalation that threatens the truce.

Furthermore, Israel made clear that it views the ceasefire with Iran as an operational opportunity. Israeli officials noted that by reducing operations over Iran, the Air Force was able to concentrate on Lebanon, intensifying the offensive against Hezbollah.

The situation on the ground has deteriorated further. Israel expanded “evacuation” orders in Beirut, attacking southern suburbs and areas near the airport, while Hezbollah responded with attacks against Israeli forces. The dynamic of action and reaction increases the risk of a regional escalation that could drag Iran back into the conflict.

Read alsoCeasefire yes, but not in Lebanon: will an increase in attacks in the country cause the regional truce to collapse?

Strait of Hormuz: energy and military pressure

The second critical focus is the Strait of Hormuz, through which a fifth of the world's oil transits. The Israeli and American attacks caused a de facto closure of the sea route by Tehran and the truce has not significantly changed the situation.

Semi-official Iranian agencies released graphics suggesting the laying of naval mines by the Revolutionary Guard, increasing uncertainty about the security of the route. In the first 24 hours of the ceasefire, only six ships crossed the strait, far from the nearly 140 that usually did so.

More than 230 oil tankers remained waiting to cross, according to energy authorities in the United Arab Emirates, as crude oil prices remained at high levels. Brent reached $98, an increase of 35% since the start of the conflict, and some refineries paid levels close to $150 per barrel.

Iran conditioned the normalization of traffic on the United States reducing its military pressure and Israel ceasing attacks on Lebanon. In this way, the strait has become a key negotiating instrument.

To display this content from X (Twitter), you must allow audience measurement and advertising cookies.

In addition, Tehran is raising the possibility of establishing a charging system for the transit of ships, which would alter decades of free navigation and consolidate its influence over one of the most important energy corridors in the world.

Read alsoFear of mines and attacks in Lebanon cloud the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz

Iranian nuclear program: at the center of the conflict

Beyond the immediate tensions, the main strategic obstacle remains the Iranian nuclear program. The United States demands a complete end to uranium enrichment and the elimination of existing stockpiles, while Iran insists its program is peaceful and claims the right to continue enrichment.

Iran is estimated to hold more than 400 kilograms of near-weapons-grade enriched uranium, despite US and Israeli attacks. The head of the Iranian nuclear agency reiterated that protecting that right is "necessary" for any negotiations.

Washington also demands that Iran abandon its missile program and stop supporting allied groups in the region. Tehran, for its part, demands the complete lifting of sanctions and the recognition of its regional influence.

The positions reflect a gap that is difficult to close.

Ambiguities of the agreement and crossed accusations

Another element that weakens the truce is the lack of clarity about the terms of the agreement. Iran maintains that several clauses have been violated, while the United States claims that those provisions were never part of the pact.

Analysts warn that this ambiguity creates fertile ground for disputes. The talks start from "very weak foundations," according to diplomats and experts, making it difficult to build trust between the parties.

Beyond the inclusion of Lebanon, there are questions about the fate of Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium, how and when normal maritime traffic through the strait will resume, and what will happen to Iran's ability to launch missile attacks in the future.

Israel's role adds uncertainty. Some analysts believe that Benjamin Netanyahu's government could push to restart the conflict with the aim of weakening the Iranian leadership, which would further complicate diplomacy.

Talks in Islamabad: limited expectations

The first negotiations after the war, scheduled in Islamabad, are taking place under strong security and with moderate expectations. The United States will send a delegation led by Vice President J.D. Vance, while Iran could be represented by senior political officials.

However, diplomats say a comprehensive agreement is unlikely to be reached in the short term. Most plausible would be a series of partial agreements that address urgent issues, such as reopening the Strait of Hormuz or limited sanctions relief.

Additionally, the US negotiating team has been criticized for a lack of experts on Iran, which could make the process difficult.

Read alsoNetanyahu affirms that he gave instructions to start direct negotiations with Lebanon

Internal pressures and risk of escalation

Both Washington and Tehran face domestic political pressures. In the United States, rising energy prices and political divisions complicate the government's position. In Iran, the leadership is trying to present the truce as a victory after surviving the military offensive.

Both sides maintain military forces in the region and have warned of possible retaliation if the agreement is broken. The United States said it would respond more forcefully to violations, while Iran maintains its missile and drone capabilities.

The ceasefire between the United States and Iran rests on a fragile balance. The bombings in Lebanon, the uncertainty in the Strait of Hormuz, the disputes over the nuclear program and the ambiguity of the agreement constitute a high-risk scenario.

Although both sides have incentives to avoid a new war, the build-up of tensions and the lack of consensus on key issues make the truce seem more like a tactical pause than the beginning of a lasting solution.

Read alsoChronicle of a negotiation: this is how the United States and Iran reached the fragile truce

With Reuters, AP and local media

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.