After Donald Trump threatened to destroy "an entire civilization" in Iran, his comments reignited calls to invoke the 25th Amendment. This procedure makes it possible to dismiss a president deemed incapable of exercising his functions. A mechanism beyond political reach, even if indications suggest a decline in the popularity of the tenant of the White House.

Published on: 04/11/2026 - 3:32 p.m. Modified on: 04/11/2026 - 3:32 p.m.

No stranger to controversies, Donald Trump reached a new milestone on April 7 by threatening to destroy “an entire civilization” in Iran. These remarks provoked a rare protest even in his own camp.

On the Democratic side, the reaction was immediate. More than 70 elected officials questioning the mental abilities of the American president have called for his dismissal. Some have invoked the 25th Amendment – ​​which allows the vice president and the Cabinet to declare that a president is no longer capable of holding office – and others have filed articles of impeachment.

More strikingly, certain conservative figures also reacted strongly. "25TH AMENDMENT!!! Not a single bomb fell on America. We cannot kill an entire civilization. This is evil and madness," former Georgia Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene wrote on X. She was once one of Donald Trump's strongest supporters. Another of his former followers, Tucker Carlson, accused him of threatening "a war crime, a moral crime."

Also read: Talks between Iran and the United States: many questions, few answers

Signs of unease have also emerged among the American president's strongest allies. Trisha Hope, a January 6 activist and former die-hard supporter who campaigned for those convicted after the Capitol assault, broke rank, writing on

The day after his controversial remarks, Donald Trump announced a two-week ceasefire with Tehran. But the political storm has shown no sign of abating.

A constitutional mechanism which “has never been invoked”

The 25th Amendment was ratified following the assassination of President John F. Kennedy in 1967. It established a clear line of presidential succession and established in Section 4 a procedure for removing a president deemed incapable of carrying out his duties. But this mechanism is far from simple and "has never been invoked", as Mario Del Pero, professor of American politics at Sciences-Po Paris, explains.

The vice president and the majority of the cabinet must first send a written statement to both houses of Congress stating that the president is unable to carry out his role. The vice-president then immediately becomes acting president. But if the president contests this decision – which Donald Trump certainly would – the question returns to Congress. A two-thirds majority in the House of Representatives and the Senate is then necessary to uphold impeachment.

See also Trump's threats to Iran: can the 25th Amendment be activated for incapacity to exercise?

“What we are seeing today, and what we also saw after January 6, 2021, has no precedent as a large-scale political and public debate,” said Mario Del Poro.

A cabinet of “ultra-loyalists” and a base that holds up

The closest the 25th Amendment came to being invoked was in the final days of Donald Trump's first term, immediately after January 6, 2021. That ultimately did not happen. And the obstacles today are even greater.

The current cabinet of the American president is made up of “ultra-loyalists and fanatics”, according to Mario Del Poro. The vice-president, for his part, maintains a certain closeness with Donald Trump. This week, J.D. Vance – the main potential player in any invocation of Section 4 – was in Budapest. He called the American president on the phone to address the crowd at a political rally in support of Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán. No cabinet member has publicly broken with Donald Trump over rhetoric on Iran.

Denis Lacorne is equally skeptical about a possible invocation of the 25th amendment. “It never works, unless the president is in a coma. There are so many restrictions. In reality, it’s useless,” explains the distinguished political scientist who has studied American presidents since the 1960s.

Also read: From the threat of annihilation to the ceasefire: how Donald Trump is sowing chaos against Iran

Furthermore, the cracks remain superficial even within Maga, maintains Denis Lacorne. The figures who have spoken out against Donald Trump have real influence as commentators and public figures, but do not represent widespread base collapse. “The average Maga voter follows Trump, not Tucker Carlson,” adds Mario Del Pero.

Unprecedented language in American political history

As the political mechanism surrounding the 25th Amendment shows its limits, Donald Trump's current rhetoric is unprecedented in American history for an American head of state. In the media The Atlantic, historian Barbara A. Perry notes that all previous American presidents have sought, despite their faults in private circles, to appear measured and responsible when addressing the nation on the subject of the war.

Richard Nixon's crude diatribes were confined to recorded conversations with those around him. Even during the 1979 Iranian hostage crisis, Jimmy Carter, a former naval officer, favored patient diplomacy over incendiary public discourse, believing that aggressive language would endanger the 66 Americans held in Tehran.

Also, Donald Trump's publication on Easter Sunday, calling Iranian leaders "crazy" and warning them that they would "live in hell", contrasts radically with "his predecessors, even the crudest", according to Barbara A. Perry.

Maintain the unity of the loyal Maga base

If impeachment seems out of reach as long as Republicans control both chambers, and the 25th Amendment is politically ineffective, the most effective checks and balances against Donald Trump have come from the courts. Federal judges have blocked several presidential executive orders on constitutional grounds. Even the Supreme Court, generally favorable to the administration's program, blocked certain major initiatives, notably regarding customs duties, inflicting a significant setback on the president.

A Democratic victory in the midterm elections next November could further change the equation. Control of the House of Representatives would give them chairs of key committees with subpoena power. This would open the way to investigations into the Trump family's affairs, its investments in cryptocurrencies or even financial ties between the Gulf states and the administration.

For Mario Del Pero, "if major scandals break out, there could be an opening for impeachment proceedings. But that is a distant future." For now, Donald Trump's political survival rests on a single variable: the loyalty of the Maga base and his unique ability to keep it united. “Trump plays the Maga, he absorbs even the most radical political about-faces,” concludes the professor of American politics. “Remove Trump and divisions within Maga will explode.”

This article is an adaptation by Jean-Luc Mounier of the original paper in English available here.

Keywords associated with the article

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.