Image source, Sunil Pradhan/Anadolu via Getty Images
Nepal's Prime Minister Balen Shah will visit India on 22 and 23 November. Before this, Nepal's media is putting forward both big questions and expectations regarding this tour.
Some media outlets are linking it to BP Koirala's historic visit to Delhi in 1960 and are suggesting the possibility of a new chapter in India-Nepal relations, while some are demanding concrete progress on pending issues like border dispute, 1950 treaty, trade imbalance and water resources.
At the same time, some analysts are also keeping an eye on the ambitious initiative of Balen Shah, under which he wants to increase cooperation between India, Nepal and China to deal with the climate crisis.
Nepal's young PM met Nehru for the first time, now Modi's turn
Image source: Sushil Koirala Memorial Foundation
Swaran Singh, former professor of International Studies in JNU, has underlined the visit of Nepal's young PM Balen Singh to New Delhi on Sunday as a visit that is taking place after six decades.
In an article published in The Kanthamadu Post, he has written in detail about this journey with co-author Sriprakash Devkota.
He wrote that in the year 1960, Nepal's first democratically elected Prime Minister BP Koirala, who was then young, had visited India. He met the then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru who was in power for 12 years.
Then their Joint Communiqué of 28 January 1960 had made sovereign equality, territorial integrity and mutual economic cooperation the cornerstone of bilateral relations.
Image Source: X/SwaranSinghJNU
Swaran Singh has written in the article, "The current Indian PM Modi has also been in power for 12 years. And 36-year-old Nepali PM Balen Shah, who is meeting him on his first foreign trip, represents a generation that does not want to wait any longer to see these unfulfilled promises come true.
End
Although he writes that the basic spirit of the relationship between the two countries has remained intact over time, but compared to the era when Koirala and Nehru met, the geopolitical scenario of India-Nepal relations has changed dramatically today.
"Nepal's economic and strategic relations with China have become more important and influential than ever before."
He also adds that unlike his predecessor KP Sharma Oli, Balen Shah has chosen India instead of China for his first foreign trip.
He believes that in such a situation, New Delhi should also give a positive reply.
He writes, "India should use this opportunity to make its relations with Nepal stronger and more attractive through reliable connectivity, timely investment and greater sensitivity towards Nepal's sovereign decisions."
'India does not take concrete steps on controversial issues'
Image source, PRAKASH MATHEMA/AFP via Getty Images
Nepal's national daily 'Kantipur' has published an article regarding PM Balen Shah's visit to India and controversial issues.
It says that in the last three and a half decades, 19 Prime Ministers of Nepal have visited Delhi.
The newspaper writes, “When he returned, he gave mostly the same message – it was agreed to continue discussions on the border issue and the 1950 treaty. Now the current Prime Minister of Nepal is about to visit.
In the same article, former Nepalese Foreign Minister Pradeep Kumar Gyawali has been quoted as saying regarding the controversial issues that India listens to the concerns of Nepal, but does not take concrete steps on issues like border dispute, 1950 treaty, water resources and trade agreements.
Gyawali further says, "In some cases, India's commitment is not even visible. The experience so far shows that India has not been cooperative, generous and ready for solutions on issues of grave concern to Nepal."
The newspaper quoted former Prime Minister Baburam Bhattarai as saying, "The problems between the two countries should not be resolved in pieces, but comprehensively."
"Unless the 1950 treaty is upheld and a comprehensive solution is provided to the problems, Nepal's dependency will not be resolved."
Let us tell you that in 1950, it was decided to make a treaty of peace and friendship between the two countries.
Former Prime Minister of Nepal says that Nepal should strongly raise issues like border dispute, trade deficit, access to air routes and hydropower projects with India.
Besides, trilateral cooperation between India, Nepal and China should also be promoted to deal with the growing climate crisis in the Himalayas.
Challenge of bringing India-China together on climate change
Image source, Selcuk Acar/Anadolu via Getty Images
An article published in Nepal's leading news portal Online Khabar has questioned whether PM Balen Shah will be able to bring India and China together on the issue of climate cooperation.
The article says, "After the Rasuwa-Gyirong floods, Nepal's Prime Minister Balen Shah has proposed that Nepal, India and China work together to deal with disasters caused by climate change in the Himalayan region."
He talked about sharing satellite data between the three countries in the United Nations, monitoring glaciers, giving timely warnings and increasing cooperation during disasters.
Balen Shah is on a visit to India a month after presenting this proposal in the UN. This visit is being considered as an opportunity to take his idea forward.
"However, the question is whether Nepal will be able to make this initiative an important part of its foreign policy and whether it will be able to persuade India and China to cooperate on an issue that is affecting the lives and livelihoods of millions of people across the region."
What did the main opposition party demand from Balen Shah?
Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava
Learn more
Nepal's main opposition party Nepali Congress has appealed to Prime Minister Balen Shah to give priority to national interests, implement old agreements and promises, and resolve pending bilateral issues during his visit to India.
According to news portal Nepal News, the party said that issues related to climate change, trade, energy, tourism, air connectivity, border management and Nepali workers working in India should also be taken up on priority.
Senior vice president of the party, Vishwa Prakash Sharma said in a statement that this visit should serve the best interests of Nepal and should also prove helpful in further strengthening the relations between the two countries.
Also, emphasis has been laid on taking India-Nepal relations forward on the basis of mutual respect, sovereign equality and common interests.
Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.
Download the new BBC World Service app
Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place
Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
short video
end of short video




