image copyrightReuters

The International Court of Justice's ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya people is historic. Myanmar now carries the stigma of being the first country to be found guilty of violating the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.

The Rohingya finally get long overdue justice. In 2017, Myanmar security forces and local militias attacked Rohingya communities, killing at least 10,000 people.

More than 1 million Rohingya refugees have been living in large refugee camps in Bangladesh since they fled the tragedy in 2017. Local people gathered in front of the screen to watch Justice Iwasawa, President of the United Nations International Court of Justice (ICJ), read out the ruling.

He recalled some of the evidence the court had heard since Gambia filed proceedings in 2019 with support from the Organization of Islamic Cooperation. Evidence describes mass killings, rape, torture, and the destruction of villages; Rohingya residents were sometimes burned alive in their own homes.

End of content

The ICJ’s 9:6 ruling will also have a significant impact on other genocide cases currently before the court, as it reaffirms and clarifies the evidentiary standards required to prove genocidal intent.

These include South Africa's case against Israel for committing genocide against the Palestinians in Gaza in response to the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023. Israel has repeatedly and strongly denied the accusations.

The landmark ruling also lends further support to those who believe in international rules established after World War II to regulate how power is used. The 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide is an important part of the international system after the establishment of the United Nations. It aims to prevent a recurrence of the unbridled atrocities, wars and genocide that occurred in the years before the Nazis' defeat.

International rules and conventions established after 1945 are facing unprecedented pressure in the era of US President Donald Trump (Trump), Russian President Vladimir Putin (Vladimir Putin) and Chinese President Xi Jinping. On the same day as the leaders of the three countries held a summit in China, the International Court of Justice issued a reminder that international law still exists and may be able to show that the use of force against civilians comes with a price.

End of Hot Reading

Legal insiders will scrutinize how The Gambia proves a crucial point: that the Myanmar government intended to commit genocide.

Proving intent is the biggest challenge in genocide cases before the International Court of Justice. It is not enough to prove that an atrocity occurred.

The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, adopted by the United Nations after the Nazi massacre of European Jews, provides a key definition of this crime, stating that genocide refers to "the deliberate destruction, in whole or in part, of a national, ethnic, racial or religious group."

image copyrightNurPhoto via Getty Images

Those led by Holocaust survivor Raphael Lemkin, who were responsible for developing the convention after World War II, deliberately set a strict threshold of proof.

This is why the International Court of Justice took so long to rule that genocide had been committed.

From the ideal perspective of legal professionals and investigators, they would want to obtain government documents and military orders as evidence. But in reality, it is very difficult or even impossible to obtain this information.

A government with genocidal intent does not openly promote its goals. Instead, the court inferred evidence of genocidal intent from actions taken by Myanmar security forces and local militias against the Rohingya.

Prof Janina Dill, chair professor of global security at the Blavatnik School of Government, University of Oxford, said:

"Genocidal intent can be inferred from a pattern of behavior... This does not mean that all atrocities must have the sole purpose of genocide. If this were the case, it would be sufficient to deny genocidal intent simply by showing that the atrocity also involved other purposes (such as counterinsurgency operations, punishment, or forced population transfers)."

"The court made it very clear that these goals were legitimate, but ruled that all the evidence could not be interpreted without genocide being one of the goals."

In other words, even if a country is attacked and orders its military to go on the offensive in self-defense, the sum of its actions may still amount to genocide.

The judge made it clear that each case must be decided on its own merits. However, the Myanmar case does have implications for other genocide cases pending before the ICJ, as the court's rulings can affect how the law is interpreted. Among them, the case that attracted the most attention was South Africa's case against Israel for killing Palestinians and causing large-scale destruction in Gaza.

Britain's Philippe Sands KC, a member of Gambia's legal team, was in the International Court of Justice in The Hague to hear the ruling. Sands said in an interview with the BBC program "World at One" that the Gaza issue was "the elephant in the room" when the International Court of Justice addressed the Myanmar case in January this year. "Everyone knows that the way the court handles this case will have an impact on the next case."

He told the BBC that the approach taken by the ICJ judges in the Myanmar case clarified the evidentiary standards required by the court to prove genocide.

"If Gambia loses, South Africa's case will effectively come to an end."

"But now that Gambia has won the case, South Africa still has the opportunity to move forward with the case. This does not mean that South Africa will definitely win the case, nor does it mean that the International Court of Justice will find that genocide occurred in Gaza. This means that the court has very clearly defined the standard of proof, and then all parties in the next case and other cases must meet these standards."

For the Rohingya in refugee camps in Bangladesh, the ruling will undoubtedly bring joy and comfort, but it will not immediately improve their lives. For nearly a decade, they have been forced to endure harsh and dangerous living conditions.

The ICJ has no mechanism to enforce its ruling, but it has asked Myanmar to pay compensation to the Rohingya.

It's not easy. Hundreds of villages have been razed to the ground, and the Myanmar government is unlikely to silently accept the court's ruling.

As the so-called "pen holder" of the UN Security Council responsible for diplomacy on Myanmar, the UK issued a statement stating that the UK is "determined to take action to ensure that there is accountability for these horrific crimes... We must ensure that the court's ruling sends a clear message that no one can commit such crimes with impunity."

Britain has called for an emergency Security Council meeting, announced the expulsion of Myanmar's defense attaché in London, and promised to take other measures in the coming days.

However, it may be difficult for the United Nations to do much. Any tough resolution against Myanmar is likely to be vetoed by China or Russia, or even both countries at the same time.

There are also different voices regarding this case from the Trump administration. Long before the ICJ's ruling, former U.S. President Biden's government announced in 2022 that the Myanmar military had committed genocide against the Rohingya people.

But Mike Waltz, the current US ambassador to the United Nations, warned the ICJ last month against "lowering the legal threshold for proving genocide".

Walz said he spoke out to protect "soldiers of the United States and our allies," but his remarks were widely interpreted as supporting Israel's defense position at the International Court of Justice.

He condemned the international community's so-called "left-wing, global, anti-Semitic agenda" and singled out Navi Pillay, this year's Nobel Peace Prize winner. Pillai was one of the presiding judges in the Myanmar case.

Pillay previously headed an independent international commission of inquiry for the United Nations. The committee issued a report a year ago stating that Israel had committed genocide against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip.

But whatever threats the Trump administration makes, seeking justice for the Rohingya will surely refocus attention on Israel's conduct in Gaza, South Africa's lawsuit at the International Court of Justice, and the ongoing plight of Palestinians.

Gaza is now in ruins, and Israel is still killing more than 1,400 people there after a ceasefire agreement came into effect more than a year ago.

Legal experts point out that the Myanmar case should not be seen as a preview of the case against Israel.

“This risks distracting from the Rohingya, who should be the focus of our attention,” said Janet Dill of the University of Oxford.

"The litigation surrounding their suffering is not a test case for a conflict that the world has chosen to devote more attention to."

This article was originally written in English. We used artificial intelligence to assist with translation and was reviewed by BBC journalists before publication. Learn more about how we use artificial intelligence.

Explore more

More short films

More short films end

Analysis: The battle for voice behind the Rohingya issue

Rohingya who may be sent back to Myanmar

Myanmar social media storm turns Facebook into a ‘beast’

The fear of young people in Myanmar: Walking on the streets, they will be "caught" at any time and sold to the military

Are the Myanmar people’s revolutionary dreams disillusioned because of China’s renewed toughness against the military government?

Myanmar Military Government: King Charles presents book to Aung San Suu Kyi

headlines

The trilateral summit between China, Russia and the United States is more spectacular than substantive results - Analysis by BBC North America correspondent

The far-reaching historical significance of Myanmar’s genocide verdict

Changing from Taiwan’s Cangjie to Mainland China’s Hanyu Pinyin: Will the computer input method affect the next generation’s learning of Chinese?

Special recommendation

Popular content