image copyrightEPA
Before the trilateral meeting between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, there was not much on the agenda and no clear demands. After the meeting, he did not achieve any substantive results.
In the end, the most profound impression left by this summit may only be the spectacle of the meeting - the "look and feel" as political commentators often say. Some people have described this meeting as a historic "Yalta 2.0", a metaphor for the leaders of the three major powers reuniting to discuss world order.
After all, pageantry and ceremony may be exactly what Trump wants most. The Republican Party suffered a heavy setback in the congressional midterm elections earlier this month, and Trump's political popularity took a hit; he clearly enjoyed the global attention brought by this three-day trip to Asia and the historic scene of the first trilateral summit between the United States, China and Russia.
End of content
In an interview with Fox News on Wednesday (November 18), Trump specifically mentioned his prominent seat at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) dinner on Tuesday (17th) and the grand reception he received when he arrived in China - "a grand scene, beautiful decorations, a grand ceremony, and thousands of people" - as proof that the trip had been successful.
This standard of success may seem quite low, but it may be enough for Trump.
This article contains content provided by Instagram. Because this content uses technology such as cookies or cookies, we will seek your consent before loading any content. You may wish to read the Instagram Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy before giving your permission. If you wish to read the above, please click "Accept and Continue".
Ending Instagram Post
However, after the tripartite meeting ended, the United States' response so far has been surprisingly low-key.
China quickly issued a communiqué detailing the contents of the talks; Putin also held an hour-long press conference after the meeting to elaborate on the results of the talks. In contrast, Trump has made almost no public comments and only stated that he will hold a press conference at the White House on Friday (20th).
After Trump visited China earlier this year and met with Xi Jinping during the APEC summit in South Korea last October, he took questions from reporters at the beginning of his return flight to the United States.
End of Hot Reading
Currently, the White House issued a joint communiqué after the meeting. However, most of the contents of the communiqué are general, and only outline support for all parties' efforts to ensure "strategic stability and international security."
The image of three powerful leaders sitting in the same room and discussing global issues amicably may give the outside world some reassurance that the world is not about to erupt into a catastrophic conflict. However, the communiqué's promise to continue "dialogue" and its recognition that nuclear war "must never happen" are very limited in substance beyond diplomatic rhetoric.
David Firestein, chairman of the Bush Foundation for US-China Relations, told the BBC: "In summary, when leaders of the world's major powers come together in different forms, it is usually a good thing, even if the results appear to be limited at best."
One of the communiqués' reference to strengthening "the production and supply of refined petroleum products" appears to be directed at Putin. Because Russia is one of the major suppliers of fossil fuels on the international market. In addition, the language of the communique condemning the International Criminal Court (ICC) is also quite eye-catching - the court has been the target of criticism from the United States recently.
If there is one thing that the leaders of the world's three largest powers can agree on, it is that multilateral international organizations that seek to enforce international law should not have sufficient real power to do so.
While in China, Trump called Putin his "friend" and praised the "extraordinary personal relationship" between the two after shaking hands and hugging Xi Jinping.
But when Trump returns to Washington, he is likely to face a mix of domestic political reactions, ranging from cautious concern to outright criticism.
Utah Republican Senator John Curtis told the BBC on Thursday (19th): "I am concerned about how we describe our relationship with our geopolitical opponents. Putin and Xi Jinping are not our friends."
"Diplomacy is important, but it must not come at the expense of obscuring the identity of our adversaries," he added.
Illinois Republican Rep. Darin LaHood was re-elected earlier this month with Trump's support. He said the United States should talk to overseas allies and adversaries, but he also called Putin a "dictator" and an "international criminal."
He told the BBC: "I'm a little worried that having him appear on the world stage will make the outside world think that he is on an equal footing with the United States."
"We must remember what Putin did in Ukraine. He invaded a sovereign, independent country with a democratically elected government and continues to carry out aggressive actions there today."
Democrats were unsubtle in their criticism.
"America's security cannot be sacrificed for photo opportunities or personal vanity," nine senators on the Foreign Relations Committee wrote in a joint letter to the White House.
Trump is not the first U.S. president to seek an international diplomatic breakthrough to restore his reputation after suffering domestic political setbacks. Former Democratic presidents Clinton and Obama also visited overseas as presidents shortly after their parties lost the midterm elections.
But in both cases, the prestige boost brought by the trip was short-lived. Trump may have gotten the picture he wanted at the Asia summit, but the trip is likely to be forgotten just as quickly due to the lack of real progress.
Additional reporting: Brandon Drenon
This article was originally written in English. We used artificial intelligence to assist with translation and was reviewed by BBC journalists before publication. Learn more about how we use artificial intelligence.
Explore more
More short films
More short films end




