image copyrightReuters

Nine years after the Myanmar military murdered thousands of Rohingya, a Muslim minority in the country, the United Nations' International Court of Justice (ICJ) recognized Myanmar's responsibility for genocide.

The decision, handed down by the ICJ panel of 15 judges elected from around the world, is the first time an international court has found a state guilty of the crime of genocide.

This is expected to affect other future genocide-related lawsuits, including the case filed by South Africa against Israel in relation to the Gaza War.

Proof of ‘intention to commit genocide’

In the wake of the Nazi Holocaust, the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide (Genocide Convention) was signed in 1948 and came into effect in 1951, defining genocide as a crime.

During World War II, 6 million Jews and millions of members of other minority groups were murdered.

Genocide is defined as “an act committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group” and is considered the most serious crime against humanity.

However, to establish guilt, very strong evidence is needed to prove intent to commit genocide. This is quite difficult to prove in cases where the intention to commit genocide is not explicitly revealed, such as in the Nazi case.

To date, all those found guilty of genocide in international courts have been individuals. These include those responsible for the 1994 massacre of hundreds of thousands of members of the Tutsi minority in Rwanda and the 1995 systematic murder of thousands of Bosnian Muslim men and boys in Srebrenica, Bosnia.

End of TOP News

They were found guilty of genocide by a specially established tribunal.

In the case of the Srebrenica massacre, individuals were found guilty, but after a 14-year trial, the ICJ concluded that while Serbia was responsible for failing to prevent the massacre, there was not enough evidence to suggest there was intent to commit genocide at the state level.

The ICJ cannot rule on individuals; it can only rule on countries.

With this ruling, Myanmar became the first country to be recognized as violating the 1948 UN Genocide Convention.

End of content

‘Intent to destroy’

The ICJ determined that 10,000 Rohingya people died as a result of brutal repression by the Myanmar military in 2017. At that time, more than 700,000 Rohingya fled to the neighboring country of Bangladesh.

Two years later, Gambia filed a complaint to the ICJ, claiming that Myanmar had committed genocide by committing mass murder and sexual violence against civilians and destroying villages. Myanmar has denied these allegations.

The Myanmar government has always claimed that the measure was aimed at Rohingya militants. Earlier this year, a representative of the Myanmar government emphasized in court that Myanmar “could not stand by and allow terrorists to run wild in northern Rakhine State.”

ICJ Director Yuji Iwasawa acknowledged that there had been attacks committed by the Rohingya armed group 'Arsa' before August 2017, but pointed out that Myanmar security forces had "killed thousands of Rohingya civilians" trying to escape to Bangladesh.

It added that the scale and nature of Myanmar's actions "intend to destroy a significant portion" of the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine state.

Justice Iwasawa also ruled that Myanmar authorities committed “extensive destruction of evidence” through post-mortem processing, such as burning the bodies, and failed to investigate, prosecute, and punish those who committed the crime of genocide.

Justice Iwasawa explained that the court's position is that if "a state agency or an individual or group whose actions can be attributed to the state" commits genocide or other acts, the state can be held responsible. He then stated that while individuals bear criminal responsibility, states bear obligations under international law.

Rohingya human rights activist Yasmin Ullah, who was interviewed by BBC's 'Newsday' ahead of the ruling, said it was "a historic moment for the Rohingya people."

Ulla was among those who were forced to leave their homeland with their families, and lived in Thailand "without any legal status" before moving to Canada.

However, he said, “If their lives do not change substantially, justice cannot be considered truly achieved,” and urged Myanmar authorities to take responsibility for compensation and restoration of rights for the Rohingya’s “safe, voluntary, and dignified return.”

Meanwhile, the ICJ is not a criminal court, and its enforcement powers are limited. The ICJ cannot send military officials directly to prison and must rely on the UN Security Council and political pressure to actually enforce its rulings.

convincing evidence

As genocide-related cases are rare at the ICJ, this ruling could serve as an important precedent in judging similar cases in the future.

Maria Elena Vignoli of the international human rights organization Human Rights Watch (HRW) said that this ruling "will set an important precedent in the process of seeking justice for victims of genocide and other serious crimes around the world."

This case shows how intent to commit genocide can be proven in the UN's highest court.

Oliver Windridge, a former UN lawyer, told BBC News that the ruling shows that states can be held accountable for genocide if there is sufficient circumstantial evidence to prove intent to commit genocide, without an explicit written order or official policy.

“This is a case showing that existing (proving) standards can be met if the evidence is sufficiently convincing.”

Moreover, Gambia filed this lawsuit even though its citizens did not suffer direct damage. Gambia used the provisions of the UN Genocide Convention at the time as its basis, and in fact, according to the convention, any party can sue another party for violating the convention.

This is a provision that was also applied when South Africa filed a lawsuit against Israel at the end of 2023. South Africa accused Israel of genocide during the Gaza War, saying it was "trying to destroy the Palestinian people in the Gaza Strip."

However, Israel completely denies these claims and claims that these claims about its military response to Hamas attacks are "completely unfounded" and based on "biased and false claims."

In January of this year, the ICJ issued an interim measures order urging Israel to take steps to prevent genocide in the Gaza Strip, but did not order an immediate halt to military operations.

It has not yet been concluded whether genocide actually occurred in the Gaza Strip.

Gambia's lawyer Philip Sands pointed out, "If Gambia had lost (in this case), the lawsuit filed by South Africa would have virtually been defeated."

In an interview with the BBC's 'World at One' program held outside the court, lawyer Sands said, "But thanks to this ruling, we can say that the door to justice is still open."

“Of course, this does not mean that the ICJ will conclude that it is responsible for genocide in Gaza. This case means that the evidentiary standards for proving (genocide) are very clearly defined, and the parties in that case and other cases in the future will have to meet these standards.”

However, Sands also emphasized that the ICJ worked very hard to clearly show that "every case depends on its unique facts."

Learn more

The Myanmar military massacred the Rohingya people... Now, on the contrary, you want their help?

Has the international community forgotten about Rohingya refugees?

At least 23 dead when boat carrying Rohingya people sinks

Myanmar military reveals mass murder after torture

video

Video, 'Nobody was punished' for alleged gang rape at Cornell University, broadcast length 1,34

Video, 'Irreversible water temperature' How hot have the seas of Ulleungdo and Dokdo become, broadcast length 5,34

Video, North Korean defector women talk about dating and sex in North Korea, broadcast length 3,59

Video, from before to after the 'K-pop craze'...the path taken by female musicians, broadcast length 12,14

top news

The International Court of Justice recognizes Myanmar as responsible for the Rohingya genocide... What does this landmark ruling mean?

Analysis: 'Full of spectacular attractions'...US-China-Russia summit lacked substantive results

Trump, Putin, Xi Jinping announce 'peace declaration' after historic meeting

this time issue

Most viewed news