A few hours after he threatened Iran with the complete annihilation of its three-thousand-year-old civilization, US President Donald Trump announced on Tuesday evening a two-week truce of mutual hostilities with Iran. This dramatic acceleration in the course of events in the Middle East and the Arabian Gulf region embodies a strategy that combines extreme intimidation and clear contradictions with the American President’s attempt to regain control of the narrative and the media narrative.

Published on: 04/09/2026 - 21:20

On Tuesday morning, April 7, US President Donald Trump issued an ultimatum to Iranian leaders: reopen the Strait of Hormuz before nightfall, otherwise “an entire civilization will die tonight, never to return,” according to what he declared on his “Truth Social” platform. He added: "I don't want this to happen, but it will probably happen." A rare threat of violence, unparalleled in the contemporary rhetoric of any American president.

Less than ten hours later, and two hours before the deadline expired, there was a shift in position: Donald Trump announced his acceptance of a two-week truce with Tehran, which he immediately presented as a “complete and comprehensive victory” for Washington, despite reports of violations of the truce and errors in interpretation.

Read also: Iran requires ships crossing the Strait of Hormuz to take two alternative routes to avoid “mines”

For many observers, these verbal escalations represent a new frontier. “This is a sign of a trapped man,” says Stephen Ekovich, professor emeritus at the American University of Paris. “He is in a difficult situation, with no way out. His statements reflect deep frustration. Perhaps the Iranians saw this as weakness rather than a show of strength.”

"Intimidate the opponent"

This strategy falls, however, within a certain continuum. Trump has made his “no verbal filter” persona a political tool. Already in 2017, during his first term, he promised North Korea “fire and fury,” brandishing a nuclear threat, before embarking on unprecedented talks with Kim Jong Un.

For Jerome Fiala Godefroy, a professor at the Institute of Political Studies in Saint-Germain-en-Laye who specializes in the United States, this position falls within a specific logic: “Donald Trump raises the stakes very high because he believes that this is the solution to intimidate the opponent. He thinks that this maximum pressure will force the opponent to negotiate and give him an advantage. However, he is in a weak position vis-à-vis Iran.”

Jerome stresses that "Donald Trump, despite his very violent statements, does not get anything in reality and is involved in a situation that he caused himself. He is a Trump-style way out, a rhetorical way out. He builds a narrative in which he appears as the winner, distorting reality by asserting that the Iranians are forced to negotiate, while if he accepts the ten points of the peace plan, the situation will likely be worse than it was before the war."

Read also Live: Iran confirms that the continuation of Israeli attacks on Lebanon will make the negotiations “meaningless”

International law questions

Trump's statements also raise questions about international law. When he threatens to destroy Iran's electrical grid and return the country's 90 million people "to the Stone Age," he does not rule out committing acts that constitute war crimes.

Democratic Representative Jason Crow said on CNN that the military has a duty to reject illegal orders: "If you are asked to target civilians, if you are asked to kill women and children, if you are asked to kill non-combatants, if you are asked to bomb a school, if you are asked to bomb a civilian power plant, that would be a war crime."

The same is true of threats of complete annihilation of Iran, which have fueled speculation about the use of nuclear weapons. Reuters polled Brian Finucane, a former State Department legal adviser who now works at the International Crisis Group, who believes that these statements “could be construed as a threat to commit genocide” under US and international law.

The confusion is heightened because the US President's messages are contradictory. Two days before his ultimatum expired, he wrote on Truth Social: “Open the damned strait, you crazy people, otherwise you will live in hell - you will see!” He added: “Glory be to God.” On Tuesday, in the letter in which he threatened to obliterate Iran, he also indicated the possibility of a diplomatic solution, concluding with the phrase: “May God bless the great Iranian people.”

Keeping “the entire planet in suspense”

This sequence, however, embodies a now well-established pattern: push the threat to its peak, then adjust the position in the face of risks of escalation. This mechanism also falls within a tense domestic political context, characterized by more war-hesitant public opinion and growing economic concerns, as midterm elections approach.

For Steven Ekovich, the logic also lies elsewhere: “Donald Trump's strategy is to be at the center of global attention. He kept the entire planet on edge for a few hours after his threat on Tuesday. But it has also damaged his credibility. The danger is that no one will take him seriously anymore.”

Thorny negotiations and ongoing violations

In depth, the end of the war in the Middle East still seems far away, as the official Iranian press indicated that a ten-point proposal conveyed by Tehran will be discussed during negotiations scheduled to begin Friday in Pakistan.

A list published by the Islamic Republic mentions “maintaining Iranian control over the Strait of Hormuz, accepting enrichment, and lifting all primary and secondary sanctions,” in addition to the withdrawal of American forces from the Middle East, and stopping fighting on all fronts, including Lebanon and Iraq. Conditions that are difficult to reconcile with Washington's declared goals.

In a parallel context, US Vice President J.D. Vance stated that Tehran cannot use the Lebanon file, which is not related to the ceasefire negotiations, as an excuse for the collapse of the talks, adding that the United States has never included it among the terms of the truce, and ending the negotiations on its part remains a purely Iranian decision.

J.D. Vance's statement about Lebanon's inclusion in the truce with Iran

To view this content from Instagram it is necessary to allow the collection of views and Instagram ads.

On Thursday, the Iranian ambassador to Pakistan deleted his post on the “X” platform in which he had announced the arrival of an Iranian delegation to Islamabad on Thursday evening, in preparation for the launch of discussions with the American side. The deleted post stated that the Iranian delegation arrived to conduct a serious dialogue based on Tehran’s ten-point plan, despite the doubts of Iranian public opinion resulting from repeated Israeli violations of the ceasefire, which - according to the ambassador - aim to obstruct the diplomatic initiative sponsored by Pakistani Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif.

An Iranian embassy official explained that the post was removed due to “technical problems,” refusing to confirm whether the Iranian delegation had already arrived. For their part, Iranian officials warned that Lebanon's continued exclusion from the armistice agreement threatens the sustainability of the ceasefire.

In this context, Iranian Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Qalibaf described, on Wednesday, entering into negotiations with Washington as “illogical,” in light of what he called “violations” of Tehran’s ten-point plan, pointing to three specific violations: continued attacks on Lebanon, a drone penetrating Iranian airspace, and the American rejection of his country’s right to enrich uranium.

Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman

To view this content from X (Twitter) it is necessary to allow the collection of views and ads from X (Twitter).

On the other hand, a senior American official in the White House confirmed that the ten-year plan that Iran published publicly does not represent the real reference document on the basis of which negotiations with Washington are being conducted.

Strong political reactions inside America and calls for Trump's impeachment

In the United States, the reactions were violent. Trump's opponents question his mental health and interpret his recent statements as "evidence of his decline into dementia."

“The president’s mental capacity is collapsing,” said progressive Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Influential commentator on the American right, Tucker Carlson, directed his words at the White House and the army, called: “It is time to say no” to the president.

Indeed, many Democrats and some Republicans who oppose the president have called for invoking the 25th Amendment, which allows, through binding procedures, the forcible removal of a president believed to be incapable of performing the duties of office.

For their part, Massachusetts Senator Ed Markey and Seth Moulton, a representative from the same state in the House of Representatives, called for the initiation of impeachment proceedings against the US President. “Donald Trump simply cannot threaten to commit war crimes with impunity,” Ed Markey summarized. During his first term, Donald Trump survived two measures, each time thanks to a negative Senate vote, in February 2020 and then in February 2021.

French text: Barbara Gabel | Arabic text: Hussein Amara

Keywords related to the article

The content you want to browse is no longer in service or is currently unavailable.