“The real danger is that we weaken intellectually,” says Ugo Bienvenu, the director of the animated film “Arco,” about artificial intelligence. His first feature film is in the running for the 2026 Oscars.
Published on: 05/03/2026 - 05:11 Modified on: 05/03/2026 - 14:49
For “Arco”, his Oscar-nominated animated film, Ugo Bienvenu drew everything in 2D, in order to tell the story of a little boy from a future where humanity lives in harmony with nature, far from the robots and AI shaping our times.
“That’s why I do science fiction,” the French director, who won the Cristal at the Annecy Festival and more recently the César for best animated film, told AFP. "It was to say to the generation that is there: 'Maybe there are other outcomes, maybe there are other things to imagine.'"
Read alsoAnnecy Film Festival: “Arco” by Ugo Bienvenu receives the Feature Film Crystal
At 38, the comic book author, for whom this is his first animated feature film, is alarmed by the growing use of artificial intelligence.
“It’s not a tool,” protests this designer, very attached to the artisanal process of creation. “It’s as if we wanted, because we had a great crutch, to saw off our leg.”
A speech that goes against the directions taken by the Academy of the Oscars. Last year, it updated its rules to clarify that AI is considered a neutral tool, in the same way as special effects. Competing films can therefore use it, but are still judged “taking into account the degree to which a human was at the heart of the creative initiative”.
Defending the “muscle” of imagination
This helped to calm a campaign marked by debates around certain contenders for the Oscar for best film, such as "The Brutalist", which used AI to improve the accent of the Hungarian architect played by Adrien Brody, or "Dune: Second Part", which used it to standardize the blue eyes of the Fremen, the desert nomads of the interstellar saga.
This season, two animated short films, “Ahimsa” and “All Heart”, rushed into the door opened by the Academy by openly claiming their use of AI. They were among the hundred eligible films, but were not nominated.
For Ugo Bienvenu, this slope is dangerous. Because the imagination is a “muscle” capable of seizing up.
As an artist, "if we tell ourselves that the machine will do it for us, we never make the mistake which allows us to access our unconscious, which allows us to access our intimate practice", he believes.
The Oscar nominees' lunch at the beginning of February reassured him a little. AI was a big part of the conversation there, but according to him, “everyone is pretty much on board.”
“I have the impression that they are trying to impose it on us by force,” he says. “But in the room, what I understand is that no one really wants to use it.”
“It’s about what makes us human.”
In January, more than 800 artists, including actresses Scarlett Johansson and Cate Blanchett, as well as director Guillermo Del Toro, published an open letter accusing AI giants of "theft."
The Mexican filmmaker, whose “Frankenstein” is competing this year for the Oscar for best film, has also been protesting against this technology for years. In the field of animation, it is “an insult to life itself”, he estimated in 2022.
A line shared by Ugo Bienvenu. “The real danger is that we (...) weaken ourselves intellectually,” warns the Frenchman. “It’s not even about our jobs, it’s about what makes us human.”
For him, “fiction is about sharing experience” which allows “when something serious happens to us in life, we are a little emotionally prepared and we don’t fall apart.”
The author shudders at the idea that the horizon of part of humanity is now limited by machines, with artificially created repetitive entertainment.
“Today, there are people who consume clothes made by robots, and food made by robots, roughly speaking, it’s the poor. And today, this caste will consume fiction made by robots,” he regrets.
To avoid getting to this point, we should “tax the water it costs to produce” with AI, he judges.
In December, a study published by the Digiconomist website estimated that the annual volumes of water used by AI systems reach, or even exceed, the global consumption of bottled water.
AI, “it’s not free”, insists Ugo Bienvenu. “It has physical and unconscious repercussions.”
With AFP
Keywords associated with the article
The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.




