image source, Reuters
The ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya people is historic. Myanmar now bears the stain of being the first state found responsible for violating the 1948 Genocide Convention.
The Rohingya are receiving the justice they have been waiting for for so long. At least 10,000 people died when their communities were attacked by Myanmar security forces and local militias in 2017.
More than a million Rohingya refugees live in the huge camps in Bangladesh who fled after the terrible events that occurred a decade ago.
There, crowds gathered near the screens to watch the president of the International Court of Justice (ICJ), Judge Yuji Iwasawa, read the court's verdict.
The magistrate reviewed some of the evidence presented since Gambia brought the case in 2019, with the support of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation.
That evidence described acts of mass murder, rape, torture and the destruction of villages, sometimes with Rohingya residents burned alive inside their homes.
The validity of the right
The decision – made by a majority of nine to six at the ICJ – will also have a significant impact on other genocide cases currently being considered by the court, by reaffirming and clarifying the evidentiary standard necessary to prove genocidal intent.
Among them is the lawsuit filed by South Africa, which accuses Israel of having committed genocide against the Palestinian people in Gaza in its response to the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023. Israel has repeatedly and forcefully rejected that accusation.
End of Most read
The court's historic decision also reinforces the position of those who believe in the rules created to regulate the exercise of power after the Second World War.
The 1948 Genocide Convention has been a fundamental piece in the structure built around the United Nations to prevent a repetition of the unrestrained brutality, war and genocide that marked the years before the defeat of the Nazis.
All the news you need is on BBC World Service
Download it here
End of Ad app
Norms and conventions established after 1945 have come under unprecedented pressure during the era of US President Donald Trump; the president of Russia, Vladimir Putin, and that of China, Xi Jinping.
On the same day that the three held a summit in China, the ICJ issued a reminder that international law still exists and may still be able to demonstrate that the use of force against civilians has consequences.
Lawyers will study how The Gambia managed to prove the crucial point that the State of Myanmar intended to commit genocide.
Proving intent is the biggest challenge in a genocide case before the Court. Proving that atrocities were committed, in and of itself, is not enough.
The key phrase of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, adopted by the United Nations following the Nazi Holocaust against European Jews, defines the crime as "acts committed with the intention of destroying, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group."
The genocidal intention
The people who drafted the Convention in the years after World War II, led by Raphael Lemkin, a Jewish Holocaust survivor, deliberately set a very high standard of proof.
That is why it has taken so long for the ICJ to issue a ruling concluding that genocide was committed.
In an ideal world for lawyers and investigators, they would gather evidence from government documents and military orders. In practice, obtaining them is difficult, if not impossible.
Governments that have genocidal intentions do not make their objectives public.
Instead, the Court has inferred evidence of such intentions from actions taken by Myanmar security forces and local militias against the Rohingya people.
image copyrightNurPhoto via Getty Images
According to Janina Dill, Professor of Global Security at Oxford University's Blavatnik School of Government, "genocidal intent can be inferred from a pattern of behavior," she says.
"This does not mean that the commission of atrocities had to pursue a single objective: genocide. If this were the case, demonstrating that these atrocities also responded to other purposes such as counterinsurgency, punishment or forced displacement, would rule out the existence of a genocidal intention," he adds.
"The court was extraordinarily clear that these are plausible objectives, but ruled that the totality of the evidence cannot be explained without genocide being one of those objectives."
In other words, even if a state has been attacked and orders its forces to go on the offensive claiming self-defense, the sum of its actions could constitute genocide.
The repercussions of the ruling
The judges made it clear that each case had to be analyzed on its merits.
However, since the Court's decisions affect the interpretation of the law, the Myanmar case has implications for other genocide cases that the ICJ is considering. The most prominent is that brought by South Africa against Israel for the murders and destruction inflicted on Palestinians in Gaza.
British lawyer Philippe Sands KC, a member of Gambia's legal team, was present in the ICJ courtroom in The Hague to hear the verdict.
Sands told the BBC's World at One that when they argued the case against Myanmar before the ICJ in January this year, Gaza was "the taboo subject. Everyone knew that the court's stance in this case would have repercussions on the next one."
As he explained to the BBC, the approach taken by ICJ judges in the ruling on Myanmar clarifies the standard of evidence they require to prove genocide.
"If Gambia had lost, South Africa's case would, in effect, be over."
But now that Gambia has succeeded, the door remains open for South Africa. That doesn't mean South Africa will win. It does not mean that the International Court of Justice will determine that there was a genocide in Gaza.
It means that the evidentiary standard has been very clearly defined, and it will now be up to the parties, in that next case and in others, to meet those standards.
Relief without improvement
The undoubted joy and relief felt by the Rohingya in the camps of Bangladesh will not mean an immediate improvement in the precarious and dangerous living conditions they have been forced to endure for almost a decade.
The court has no mechanism to enforce its rulings, but has ordered Myanmar to compensate the Rohingya. That won't be easy. Hundreds of villages have been razed and the Myanmar government is unlikely to accept the court's verdict without resistance.
The United Kingdom – known as the pen holder (the one who carries the pen) in the UN Security Council for its responsibility in the diplomatic management of the Myanmar issue – issued a statement in which it stated that it is "determined to act and ensure accountability for these atrocious crimes."
"We must ensure that the court's ruling sends a clear message that such crimes cannot be committed with impunity," he added.
Britain has called for an urgent session of the Security Council, is expelling Myanmar's defense attaché in London and has promised other measures in the coming days.
Meanwhile, there is not much that could be achieved at the UN. A strong resolution against Myanmar could be vetoed by China or Russia, or both countries.
Rumors have also emerged from the Trump administration regarding the case.
Without waiting for the ICJ verdict, the government of former President Joe Biden declared in 2022 that the Myanmar army committed genocide against the Rohingya people.
But Mike Waltz, the current US ambassador to the UN, warned the court last month not to "lower the legal threshold for proving genocide."
Waltz claimed he was speaking to protect "American and allied soldiers," but his post has been widely interpreted as support for Israel's defense before the ICJ.
He condemned what he called the "leftist, global and anti-Semitic agenda" of the international community, and specifically singled out Navi Pillay, this year's Nobel Peace Prize laureate, who was one of the judges in the Myanmar case.
Pillay led an independent UN international commission that reported a year ago that Israel had committed genocide against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip.
The look in Myanmar
But regardless of the threats coming from the Trump administration, it is clear that bringing justice to the Rohingya people will once again focus attention on Israel's conduct in Gaza and on South Africa's case before the ICJ.
It will also highlight the plight that Palestinians continue to suffer in the ruins of Gaza, where more than 1,400 people have been killed by Israeli attacks since the ceasefire just over a year ago.
Still, according to the lawyers, it would be a mistake to consider the Myanmar case as a dress rehearsal for the case against Israel.
"This risks diverting attention from the Rohingya, who should be our main focus," according to Janina Dill of the University of Oxford.
"The litigation over their plight is not a test case for a conflict to which the world has decided to pay more attention than this one," he clarifies.
This article was originally written in English and we used an artificial intelligence tool to translate it. A BBC journalist reviewed the text before publication. Learn more about how we use AI.
Discover more
Video
End of Video




