Talks following the ceasefire between the United States, Israel and Iran are scheduled to begin on Saturday in Islamabad, Pakistan. But central questions, on the composition of the delegations, the agenda and the objectives of each remain without precise answers. At the risk of ruining everything?

Published on: 04/09/2026 - 5:56 p.m. Modified on: 04/09/2026 - 5:57 p.m.

After the concept of fog of war, does the fragile ceasefire established between the United States, Israel and Iran on Wednesday April 8 mark the emergence of that of diplomatic fog? The outline of the upcoming negotiations remains very vague, even though these crucial discussions are supposed to begin on Saturday in Islamabad.

Which countries are represented, for what purpose and on what basis for negotiations? So many questions without an obvious answer in what the American channel CNN described as a “confused” situation.

Ensuring that Iranians will not be murdered

Thus, the Iranian embassy in Pakistan first announced the arrival of the Iranian delegation on Thursday evening in Islamabad on X, before promptly deleting the message, citing "problems".

The Americans seem to have their own problems... even with the composition of their negotiating team. It is to be led by Vice-President J.D. Vance, but US President Donald Trump has cast doubt on his presence in Islamabad for "security" reasons. The authorities of the Pakistani capital have declared public holidays in Islamabad for the next few days. Although no specific reason was provided, this instruction is often given for security reasons before important diplomatic events.

“At this stage, before even wondering what will be discussed on site, it is legitimate to question the very holding of these negotiations,” estimates Scott Lucas, specialist in security issues and American foreign policy at University College Dublin.

To display this YouTube content, it is necessary to authorize audience measurement and advertising cookies.

An extension in your browser appears to be blocking the loading of the video player. To be able to watch this content, you must disable or uninstall it.

An opinion shared by Walter Posch, Iran specialist at the Institute for Peacekeeping and Conflict Management of the Austrian National Defense Academy. But for him, one of the first obstacles to overcome concerns the Iranian delegation, which "will need assurance from the United States that its members are not going to be assassinated by Israel", underlines this expert.

Scalded Iranians may indeed fear cold water: the Hebrew state had killed several members of a Hamas delegation that the United States had brought to Qatar for negotiations in September 2025.

Even if Pakistan may seem less within range of Israeli strikes than Qatar, "it is clear that one of the first things the Americans will have to do is publicly assure that Iranian negotiators are not or no longer on Israel's target list," recognizes Scott Lucas.

If the survival of the Iranians can be guaranteed, "the glimmer of hope for this phase of negotiations is that both camps want the fighting to stop", assures Walter Posch.

A 10 or 15 point agenda?

However, willpower is not enough. You still need to know on what basis to negotiate. Here again, between the 15-point proposal that Washington had submitted to Tehran, the 10-point Iranian plan and the declarations of Donald Trump, it is difficult to know on which foot to dance.

Reconciling the initial American proposal with Iranian demands would be a feat. “The views of the two parties are currently extremely far apart,” acknowledges Mehrzad Boroujerdi, an Iran specialist and dean of the College of Arts, Sciences and Education at the University of Missouri.

For Scott Lucas, it is most likely that the Americans have been tripped up by Donald Trump's statements. The American president "started by saying that the 10-point plan submitted by Iran was an acceptable basis for negotiation, but since then, White House advisers have increased efforts to move away from it, because, in fact, it does not suit Washington," said this expert.

Also read: How the Israeli occupations of South Lebanon strengthened Hezbollah

“The fact that Donald Trump mentioned the Iranian proposal means that, very probably, it will serve in one way or another as a framework for negotiations,” predicts Mehrzad Boroujerdi.

Even if the Iranians and Americans agree on the menu, nothing says that the meal will then go well. There are many opportunities to derail the talks. For example, if the Americans assert that Israel's offensive in Lebanon has no place at the negotiating table, "the Iranians risk quickly leaving, because they cannot accept betraying Hezbollah in this way," says Walter Posch.

Which does not mean that the question of the fate of the pro-Iranian armed movement in Lebanon cannot be discussed, say the experts interviewed. But "the price to be paid by the Americans would be very high and could concern, among other things, the question of the lifting of all sanctions on Iran", maintains Mehrzad Boroujerdi.

J.D. Vance, the man for the job?

It's all in the "art of the deal" so dear to Donald Trump. In other words, it is a question of people and the way of conducting negotiations. In this respect, the “presence of J.D. Vance at the head of the American delegation is rather a good thing, because he was not very favorable to this war from the start,” believes Mehrzad Boroujerdi.

The Iranians also didn't really want to find themselves facing just Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner again. Donald Trump's special envoy to the Middle East and the American president's son-in-law hardly impressed their interlocutors in Tehran in 2025 during the Iranian nuclear negotiations. The failure of these discussions then led to the massive American bombing of nuclear sites in Iran in June 2025.

J.D. Vance is, however, “more of a default choice for Donald Trump,” Scott Lucas wishes to qualify. The American president does not, in fact, have many options to supervise the Witkoff-Kushner duo, "since Secretary of State Marco Rubio has no desire to get involved in this matter and the president sent leading experts from the region to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs before the war", specifies this specialist.

Which does not mean that no one knows about Iran in the American administration anymore. “There are some in other ministries, such as Defense and National Security, who can provide their expertise,” believes Mehrzad Boroujerdi.

Also readMohammad Bagher Ghalibaf: a “hawk” of the Iranian regime as interlocutor for Washington?

Opposite, the Iranian delegation will be led by Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf, the President of Parliament. “It’s a rather reasonable choice to start negotiations,” considers Walter Posch. The former mayor of Tehran, often described as both a "hawk" of the regime and a pragmatic man, was expected to be one of the potential interlocutors in Washington favored by Donald Trump.

The advantage of his presence at the head of the Iranian delegation is that due to his military profile close to the Revolutionary Guards, "he can also bridge the gap with those who, in Iran, are opposed to negotiations", adds Walter Posch.

However, he is not a career diplomat and "when it comes to tackling the details of a more global agreement for peace, the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Abbas Araghchi, will have to play a more central role", assures this expert.

The talks which are to begin are only an aperitif, according to the experts interviewed. A first phase which will already be delicate, but far from allowing everything to be resolved. This prospect risks displeasing the American president, who is often quick to want rapid results.

Keywords associated with the article

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.