image copyrightEPA
For the first time in more than ten years, the UK is amicably discussing the cancellation of Brexit and returning to the EU. The taboo was broken by new Prime Minister Andy Burnham back in the summer, and on Friday he will sign the first agreements with the European Union at a summit in Brussels. However, there is no talk of Britain returning to the EU, and the chances of this happening in the next five to ten years are close to zero.
For at least five reasons. Here they are.
1. Britain is not ready
60% of Britons think Brexit is a mistake and want reunification, while 73% want closer relations without joining the EU, a customs union and a single market with open borders for people, goods and services.
However, this is not enough.
Polls without consequences are one thing; elections and referendums, as a result of which life changes, are another thing. So far, even the ruling Labor party is not calling back to the EU, but has only opened a discussion. The opposition, represented by the Conservatives and the Brexit party Reform UK, is against it.
The first test of the population’s resolve to move closer to Europe is scheduled only for the summer of 2029, when parliamentary elections are due to be held in the country. Without including the issue of canceling Brexit in the election program and a convincing victory in the elections, not a single political force in the country will be able to approach this project.
Moreover, for remarriage after divorce, 50/50 or even 60/40 due to supporters of the pro-European parties Labour, Lib Dems and Greens is not enough, says Jill Rutter from the think tank UK in a Changing Europe. A national consensus is needed, and this will require that the initiators of this divorce - the parliamentary opposition represented by the Conservative Party - stand under the flag of European integration.
“It’s still a long way off,” she said.
End of Most Popular
This extension will help if you have difficulties accessing the BBC Russian Service website.
Download extension
End of story Chrome browser extension - link
While the threat of Eurosceptics returning to power looms over the country, there is no chance of Brexit being cancelled, agrees Charles Grant, founder and director of the Brussels-London think tank Center for European Reform (CER).
“Well, let’s say in 2030 Andy Burnham’s government applies to return to the EU. He is unlikely to be answered with a rude refusal, but no one will agree to take Britain back while the Conservatives and Reform UK advocate a new Brexit. There is no worse nightmare for the EU than Britain entering and leaving every five years,” he writes.
But even if all the stars align, all parties decide to be friends at home and after the elections, Britain will begin negotiations with the EU in 2030, which will take years. Modern history teaches this - not a single country that joined the EU in this century has passed this path faster than in 7 years and 11 months, recalls Simon Usherwood, chairman of the Association for University Studies in Contemporary European Studies (UACES).
The record holder of the last century is Finland. It took her less than three years to join the EU, but she is a clear exception to the rule.
Moreover, even if negotiations with the EU are successful, the British will need a new referendum to approve their results. But this is only half the battle. We also need the consent of all 27 EU countries.
2. The EU is not ready
Firstly, the wounds of divorce are still fresh, and Britain's reputation leaves much to be desired. Not only did she enter the EU under special conditions - a discount on membership fees, exemption from the obligation to switch to the euro, etc. She also played a key role in writing the EU rules, which she herself rebelled against in the 2016 referendum.
“Britain has always been considered a difficult partner. Therefore, both in the EU countries and in Brussels, there will be opponents to the return of a quarrelsome relative to the European family,” notes Ian Begg, professor at the European Institute of the London School of Economics.
Secondly, the EU is completely satisfied with the current deal with Britain. It was agreed in a hurry by the Brexit ideologist Boris Johnson, and it is so terrible for the British that for many years they have not voluntarily introduced the trade restrictions and border checks allowed by the new agreement, while the Europeans enthusiastically use the new power to protect their market from British competitors.
And the EU will continue to emerge from a position of strength in any new negotiations, says Britain's leading Brexit expert Anand Menon of King's College London.
“They’re just stronger,” he said. “We need all these agreements more than they do, and they are much more important than we are.”
Both in population and in the size of the EU economy, the EU is five to six times larger than Britain. The European Union is the largest and closest market for British goods and services. They are separated by 30 km of the English Channel, and in Ireland there is even a land border.
Ten years ago, Brexit was presented to the British under the guise of freedom to trade with the whole world without regard to EU rules. No one thought then that ten years later the small but proud nations would fall under attack.
3. The world has changed
Photo copyright: Reuters
In the decade since the EU referendum, the world has experienced Covid, Russia's invasion of Ukraine, Trump's return to power, his trade wars with the rest of the world and an actual war with Iran, Chinese economic expansion and the AI revolution.
This is just a short list of the major events that have cast doubt on the dream of a small, independent Britain growing rich in a world where we trade and live according to the rules of 2016.
World problems, on the one hand, forced Britain to move closer to the EU on issues of defense, security, support for Ukraine and sanctions against Russia. On the other hand, they have alienated them from each other, as Britain gradually diverges from Europe on issues of regulating American Internet companies and confronting China.
The EU has also changed a lot during this time.
4. The EU is not the same anymore
Those now campaigning for a reversal of Brexit don't always remember how difficult it is to step into the same river twice, says Jill Rutter of UK in a Changing Europe.
“Let’s not forget that if we weren’t happy with the EU rules when we voted to leave, it’s even worse now because we haven’t been involved in writing the new rules all these years,” she said.
And every day the paths of the exes diverge more and more. And Europe has less and less time and energy to deal with the British problem from the distant past.
“The EU is focused on more pressing issues: supporting Ukraine, strengthening defense and economic security, increasing competitiveness, protecting democratic institutions,” says Fabian Zuleg of the European Policy Center (EPC).
“As important as the relationship with the UK is, it is not among the EU’s priorities unless deepening it helps solve the EU’s fundamental problems,” he writes.
Moreover, as in Britain, Eurosceptics may come to power in the EU. The first candidate is France, where presidential elections will be held in the spring. Negotiating with the EU with Marine Le Pen at the table will not be easy.
“Most Britons, especially those who support the country's return to the EU, are wary of the far right. Therefore, the success of far-right parties on the continent could undermine the image of the European Union, says Charles Grant from CER. “Besides, Le Pen’s victory will occupy the time and attention of European leaders for a long time, and the British problem is unlikely to seem a priority to them.”
5. Much ado about nothing
Brexit was invented by pro-European Tories in order to once and for all avert the main threat to the unity of the ruling Conservative Party. Nobody thought they would lose the referendum.
Now history is repeating itself. The European question has again turned from a foreign to a domestic political one.
This time, talk of reunification with Europe is playing into the hands of the ruling Labor Party. She has already lost the support of all Brexiteers, and now she does not need to fear their antagonism. But under the slogans of rapprochement with the EU, it attracts not only those disillusioned with Brexit, but also supporters of other pro-European parties, as well as young conservatives dissatisfied with the anti-European position of the main opposition party.
For all this, you don’t necessarily need to go all-in and bet on reunification with Europe. Small steps towards each other are enough. However, they take more time than negotiations on reunification, and incidental disputes over trifles spoil the blood and discourage the desire to return to life together after a divorce.
On the other hand, all other options are even worse. One of them is the Norwegian model. Rich Norway is not a member of the EU, but is part of the single market. To do this, it fully follows EU rules and pays for the association, but has no voting rights.
“So if we want all the benefits of the single market, why not rejoin the EU and get involved in setting the rules of the game?” asks Charles Grant.
But for now the ambitions are more modest.
Friday's summit between the EU and Britain is only the second after the first summit in May in 10 years. That summit was a success by today's standards, said former British ambassador to the EU Ivan Rogers.
What is success? The fact is that they met for the first time in 10 years and signed non-binding protocols of intent, from which, by the current summit, legally binding documents on cooperation in the field of youth exchanges, phytosanitary control and other boring little things should grow.
Even such a low-key event created a storm in the British press.
“Some shouted - treason, betrayal of Brexit! Complete nonsense. Others said - a breakthrough, a bright future! Exceptional nonsense. Still others yawned - melancholy, empty, we have already heard all this, no specifics. That’s not fair either,” Rogers said.
After the summit on Friday there will be no less noise. But this does not mean that Britain is even a millimeter closer to returning to the EU.
Find out more
Video playlist
End Video playlist




